When people ask if their hard cider can go bad, they are often worried that it might spoil or turn into something that would make them ill. Usually, the cider in question is often sitting in a bucket and has a crust of white or even a moldy film or layer on top of it. Sometimes, it is in a glass container but only half filled. It looks like it is bad and maybe even something that could make you ill, but the reality is usually very different. Cider is usually rather acidic and has alcohol in it. Therefore, the simple answer to the question is “no”, hard cider cannot go bad. But, as usual, we need to unpack that simple answer a bit.
Yeast creates cider by processing the sugar found in the juice. It converts this sugar into ethanol and CO2 and that combined with the acidic characteristics of apple juice means cider doesn’t spoil. At least it doesn’t spoil like meat, cheese, or even an apple might spoil. That is because the ethanol that the yeast creates is a antimicrobial and antibacterial compound. It inhibits the growth of many organisms, especially those that can make humans ill. Once cider hits a level of around 2.5% alcohol by volume, it can effectively kill most human pathogens in hours(1). Given apples are usually acidic with a pH from 3.0-4.0. This acid weakens the cell walls of organisms and makes them more susceptible to damage from antimicrobial agents. Acids make ethanol an even more effective antimicrobial compound. Ethanol is usually what limits yeast fermentation as most yeast struggle to survive above 18% ABV. Given your cider is acidic and has ethanol, it can’t really spoil. But, it can evolve.
Cider is created in an anaerobic system or at least the most desirable ciders are. The lack of oxygen forces yeast to use a less efficient pathway to create energy and reproduce. Yeast prefer to use a respiration process where oxygen is readily available to process sugar and create energy. By removing oxygen, we force the yeast to use a different pathway. This is the fermentation pathway that creates ethanol and CO2. CO2 can also have antimicrobial characteristics but ethanol tends to be the greater antimicrobial agent. However, ethanol can be broken down further, especially if it becomes exposed to oxygen. This is how vinegar is formed. Acetic acid bacteria uses the ethanol in cider and oxidizes it to create acetic acid. That means your cider can’t spoil but, it can become something else, which is vinegar. Other organisms, like film yeast can also grow on top of your cider and, this can even create a substrate for mold to grow but, the cider sitting below that film or crust is still cider. You may note that I said it’s still cider. I didn’t say it was good cider but, it’s also not bad or spoilt cider. It may be a cider with more acetic acid or aromatic compounds that you don’t enjoy, it may even have mycotoxins from mold, but fundamentally, it’s still cider.
Cider can’t go bad or spoil. It can only evolve and become vinegar and, to do that, it must have access to a lot of oxygen. The good thing is that even if your cider evolved into vinegar, you would still have a useful produce since apple cider vinegar is a great tool for preserving vegetables and making salad dressings. That is because vinegar doesn’t spoil either. When making cider, the worse thing that can happen is you end up with vinegar, which doesn’t really leave you in pickle (or maybe it does).
(1) Menz, G., Alfred, P., and Vriesekoop, F. 2011. Growth and Survival of Foodborne Pathogens in Beer. J. Food Prot. 74:1670-1675.
Don’t miss any future answers to Cider Questions. Follow me and you will get a link to my latest article delivered to your inbox. It’s that easy!
2 thoughts on “Cider Question: Can hard cider go bad?”
Greetings , Not to throw a wrench in this but what about botulism “. …. When people make pruno, they usually ferment fruit, sugar, water, and other common ingredients for several days in a sealed plastic bag. Making alcohol this way can cause botulism germs to make toxin .(poison). …”.l
Thank you for the question. The research I have read focused on other human pathogens (E. Coli, Salmonella, Listeria monocytogenes, and such). It didn’t specifically mention the Botulism bacteria so I had to do a little research (pubmed.gov). It appears the reason it would not be mentioned in human pathogens in wine and cider is because the toxins produced by C. botulinum do not grow when the pH is below 4.6, which would be very uncommon for cider or wine. It also appears that alcohol does inhibit C. botulinum but potentially at a higher level than other pathogen (>6%). Acidity is the main prevention mechanism of C. botulinum so yes, you could produce alcohol from a sugar water with no acid and potentially be at risk but cider with a low pH wouldn’t have that risk.
It is the combination of acid and alcohol that make cider and wine an uninhabitable environment for human pathogens and it appears botulism is included. Another important reason to understand your cider’s pH.